When I bought my 2020 Jeep Gladiator, the first set of shoes it rolled out on were the Falken WildPeak AT3Ws. They were the classic “do-it-all” all-terrain tires that gave me confidence on the highway and held their own on fire roads and light trails. After putting them through their paces, I eventually swapped them for a set of Nitto Trail Grappler 35s, which leaned more toward the aggressive side. But the story didn’t end there—I wanted to see what a dedicated mud-terrain could do, so I mounted up the Milestar Patagonia M/T-02.
That gave me a unique chance to live with both types of tires—an all-terrain legend and a mud-terrain challenger. This article breaks down how the Falken AT3W stacks up against the Patagonia M/T-02, so you can decide which one fits your build and driving style.
Table of Contents
- Specs & Construction Overview
- On-Road Behavior & Comfort
- Off-Road & Extreme Terrain Performance
- Durability, Wear & Tread Life
- Wet & Winter Traction
- Noise & Vibration
- Price & Value
- Who Should Choose Which Tire?
- Pros & Cons Side-by-Side
- Final Verdict & My Takeaway<
Specs & Construction Overview
Before we talk about real-world driving, let’s lay out the bones…
Falken WildPeak AT3W
- Type: All-Terrain
- Compound: Silica-rich, optimized for wet and winter grip
- Design Features: 3D Canyon sipes, heat diffuser in sidewall, rugged upper sidewall for puncture resistance
- Certifications: 3-Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) severe snow rating
- Tread Depth: ~18/32″ in most LT sizes
- Sizes: 15–22″ wheels, diameters ~28–36.5″
- Mileage Warranty: 55,000 miles (LT), 65,000 miles (P-metric)
- Weight Example: ~53 lbs (LT265/70R17)
- Max Load: ~3,200 lbs, 80 psi
Milestar Patagonia M/T-02
- Type: Mud-Terrain
- Compound: MILETECH® silica-enriched for durability
- Design Features: High-void tread pattern, self-cleaning channels, stone ejectors, cross-directional siping for strength, 3-ply sidewall
- Certifications: Not snow-rated; designed more for mud, rock, sand
- Tread Depth: ~19/32″ in many sizes
- Sizes: Popular from LT265/75R16 up to 37×12.5R17
- Weight Example: ~65 lbs (LT285/75R16)
- Max Load: ~3,750 lbs, 80 psi
- Mileage Warranty: None (normal for mud-terrains)
At a glance, the AT3W is clearly aimed at balance and longevity, while the Patagonia screams off-road muscle with its 3-ply sidewalls and knobby tread blocks.
On-Road Behavior & Comfort
Let’s be honest: most of us spend way more time on pavement than we’d like. Here’s where the differences show.
Wildpeak AT3W
When the Gladiator was still factory fresh with the AT3Ws, I loved how civilized they felt. Road noise was minimal—just a soft hum—and they tracked straight without wandering. Ride quality was comfortable, soaking up bumps without too much thump. They felt like a highway tire with a bit more muscle, which is exactly what you want in an all-terrain.
Patagonia M/T-02
Mud-terrains are notorious for being loud and rough. Surprisingly, the M/T-02s are not as obnoxious as I expected. They do growl more than the AT3Ws, especially as speed climbs, but Milestar did a nice job with the tread design to keep noise in check. Some owners even report they’re quieter than other mud-terrains like ProComps or older MTs. On the highway, they’re still firmer and transmit more vibration than the AT3Ws, but if you’re used to aggressive tread, they’re manageable.
Verdict: If you want highway comfort and quiet, the AT3W is the clear winner. If you’re willing to live with a bit more noise for off-road bite, the Patagonia holds its own.
Off-Road & Extreme Terrain Performance
Here’s where the gap widens…
Wildpeak AT3W
The Falkens always impressed me off-road for an all-terrain. They clawed confidently through dirt and gravel, aired down nicely for sand, and their snow traction was outstanding for a tire not labeled as “snow.” On rocks, they had decent sidewall protection, though I was always mindful not to push too hard. Mud was their weak point—sticky clay would clog them quickly.
Patagonia M/T-02
This is where the Patagonias shine. The big voids and stone ejectors keep mud and gravel from packing. In sand, they float well when aired down. On rocks, the 3-ply sidewalls and aggressive shoulders give you confidence to crawl without fear of sidewall tears. They’re built with enthusiast and even pro rock-crawler input, and it shows. I’ve found they bite harder and clear faster than the AT3Ws ever could.
Verdict: For light to moderate trails, AT3W is enough. For mud bogs, rock gardens, and serious terrain, the Patagonia is in a different league.
Durability, Wear & Tread Life
Wildpeak AT3W
One of the AT3W’s biggest selling points is longevity. With a 55–65k mile warranty, you can realistically expect 50k+ miles if you rotate and maintain alignment. The silica compound helps resist uneven wear. On my Gladiator, they lasted years of daily driving and trips without complaint.
Patagonia M/T-02
Mud-terrains don’t carry tread warranties, and you shouldn’t expect 60k miles. The Patagonias wear faster on pavement, but Milestar’s updated compound helps reduce chunking on rocks and keeps the tread blocks intact. They’ll hold up well off-road but don’t buy them if you’re chasing high mileage.
Verdict: AT3W for longevity, Patagonia for toughness.
Wet & Winter Traction
Wildpeak AT3W
This is Falken’s ace card. With the 3PMSF rating, they’re one of the best winter-ready A/Ts. Snow traction is excellent, and the silica compound maintains grip in cold, wet conditions. For folks in snowy states, this is a big deal.
Patagonia M/T-02
Mud-terrains can be a mixed bag in snow. The open tread helps in powder, but blocks can slip on packed ice. The Patagonia has siping to help, but it’s not snow-rated and doesn’t match the AT3W’s winter prowess. In rain, they’re adequate, but again, the AT3W inspires more confidence.
Verdict: If winter driving matters, AT3W wins hands-down.
Noise & Vibration
I’ll keep it simple:
- Wildpeak AT3W: Quiet, refined, daily-driver friendly.
- Patagonia: Louder, more vibration, but better than some mud-terrain competitors.
If you daily drive a lot of highway miles, AT3W is easier to live with.
Price & Value
Milestar’s Patagonia MT/02 tires are a great budget option.
The Wildpeak AT3Ws are mid-priced and very competitive in the all-terrain market. You get longevity, winter rating, and balance. With discounts as they’re phased out in favor of the AT4W, they’re an even better deal right now.
The Patagonia M/T-02, meanwhile, is a budget-friendly mud-terrain that’s usually cheaper than big names like BFG KM3 or Nitto Trail Grappler. You don’t get a mileage warranty, but you get a capable mud-terrain at a lower buy-in.
Verdict: AT3W for long-term value, Patagonia for aggressive off-road capability at a budget price.
Who Should Choose Which Tire?
The Falken Wildpeak AT3W is competent in rough off-road terrain.
Wildpeak AT3W Buyers:
- Daily drivers who want comfort with some trail capability.
- Overlanders who value snow performance and tread life.
- Folks who need a balance of price, quiet ride, and all-around use.
Patagonia M/T-02 Buyers:
- Off-road enthusiasts who spend weekends in mud, rocks, and sand.
- Jeep, Bronco, and truck owners who want the aggressive look and capability of a mud-terrain.
- Drivers who don’t mind sacrificing tread life and cabin quiet for rugged performance.
Pros & Cons Side-by-Side
Falken WildPeak AT3W Pros:
- Excellent on-road comfort and quiet.
- Long tread life with mileage warranty.
- 3PMSF severe snow rating.
- Solid all-around traction.
Falken WildPeak AT3W Cons:
- Average in deep mud.
- Sidewalls are not as tough as MTs.
Milestar Patagonia M/T-02 Pros:
- Aggressive mud, rock, and sand performance.
- Strong 3-ply sidewalls.
- Self-cleaning tread and stone ejectors.
- Budget-friendly mud-terrain pricing.
Milestar Patagonia M/T-02 Cons:
- No mileage warranty; shorter tread life.
- Louder and rougher on pavement.
- Not snow-rated, weaker on ice.
Final Verdict & My Takeaway
The Falken Wildpeak AT3W is a dependable on- and off-road tire.
Living with both these tires has shown me how much your tire choice shapes your driving experience. The Falken WildPeak AT3W is the definition of a dependable daily-plus-adventure tire. It’s quiet, lasts forever, and doesn’t flinch when snow falls.
The Milestar Patagonia M/T-02, on the other hand, is unapologetically aggressive. It’s built for mud, rocks, and trail punishment. On pavement, you make compromises in noise and tread life, but off-road it rewards you with traction the AT3W simply can’t match.
So which should you buy?
- If your Gladiator (or truck/SUV) spends 80–90% of its time on pavement with occasional dirt or snow, go with the Wildpeak AT3W.
- If you live for weekend trails, mud holes, and crawling rocks, and don’t mind sacrificing some comfort, go with the Patagonia M/T-02.
For me, each tire fits its season. The Wildpeak AT3Ws were perfect when the Gladiator was new and I was still logging lots of highway miles. The Patagonias make sense now that I’m chasing more rugged adventures.
Either way, you’re equipping your rig with proven rubber that fits a purpose. The key is being honest about where you drive most—and picking the tire that makes those miles more enjoyable.
A quick heads-up: If you snag something through our affiliate links or check out our sponsored content, we might earn a commission at no extra cost to you. But fear not, we’re all about recommending stuff we’re truly stoked about!